Skip to main content

Blog post #15

Through every society there has been a set social structure. The wealthy are the people in power; they rule the lives of the people below them. In the song All Along The Watchtower, Bob Dylan uses the literary techniques of dialogue to demonstrate the inequitable social structure and how there are always people trying to break that pattern.
The dialogue between the joker and the thief is used to show the two different ways people reacted to the uneven distribution of wealth and power.The joker and the thief are symbolic for the rule benders and barrier breakers in society.  As the joker starts with his reservations about business men, the "wine" they take from him represents the upper class taking away their prosperity. The upper class makes it's money off of the middle and lower classes by selling them goods for a large profit. In some kingdoms the kings would take some of the villagers crop to feed themselves and have an abundance of supplies, making the poor poorer and the rich richer. The division of wealth has always been controlled by the upper class in every society, leaving the poor to fend for themselves. Upper Classes act as a parasite on societies back sucking their livelihood for their own benefit. The joker continues, "plowmen dig my earth" demonstrating how the people have no power over anything. Even your birthright to our own possessions and to work or live on the earth can be stripped from you. the satiety of land means nothing to the upper class when they opportunity is presented to them to make a profit and benefit themselves. This can even be seen today with the pipeline protests to protect the water supply and the sacred ground in North Dakota. This ideology has been passed down through generations through people who have never met, which leads me to the conclusion that money drives people to become evil, but are not inherently evil. When a person is divided to single handedly hold more power than the many, it's in human nature for them to become narcissistic and self serving. "you and I, we've been through that ,and this is not our fate" Taking these two characters as the riders at the end, you can tell they are well traveled and have seen this social structure before. As this is not their "fate" it shows that these men are not inherently evil but did not have great wealth. Also as the thief-- a generally negatively connotated profession--was described as kind. They did not follow the status quo and therefore made their own path. This use of dialogue create this personal connection to contrast the "princes" who separated themselves from the people, almost dehumanizing them. You are able to take line 9-12 and put them at the beginning to show that this is a cycle in the human condition. Generations go through the same thing, it happens decade after decade millennium after millennium. It's a cycle that the "Thieves and jokers" have tried to break ny going down their own path, but just as a circle has no and neither does this cycle so long as people exist.








Comments

  1. I really like how deep you took the analysis of the different classes. I also like how you included references to the pipeline and the other kingdoms

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

blog post 19

(Blog post featuring my elegant 12 year old boy handwriting)

In choosing where to start, Raena and I  were originally going to start the fight much earlier. When we were talking about the characters we realized that incoming from such a royal upbringing they are used to having everything done for them. The only other fight scene we saw was very short and simple; also having  a long  drawn out scene would have been too much effort, also the characters are all very sneaky and do more behind everyones backs and have a passive approach to solving problems, so it would have been out of character to have them immediately put in full effort.
We chose the actual actions to reflect what the characters were saying, as Kent says "I tripped up thy heels" we chose 6c to swing at Oswald's feet. We had Oswald draw his sword after so that it would seem more fluid that drawing his sword as he is being swung at. We chose to have kent start the attack as he did verbally. Kent is the one br…

blog post #21

The poem Oh Captain! My Captain! by Walt Whitman, shows the importance of a true leader and the value of the loyalty held for him. A true leader is held in the minds of the people as the highest rank out of everything else within their lives.

        Even after death the crew holds the captain in the highest regard, showing he was truly a great leader. In the first stanza, the war is over and it was a victory, but the crew notices the captain lying dead on the deck. By stating the war is won before the crews men see's the captain insinuates that the captain's death was for the good of the ship, and possibly was the reason for the victory. The use of the ship crew as an analogy for people and their leader. Showing the noble death-the captain dying for the crew- is the utmost mutual respect from leader to their followers and vise versa. To be a true leader is not just to have people blindly follow you but for you to care more for these people than you do yourself. The r…

At least you didn't "m@rry" your mom

In this class we have learned that life sucks and then you die. Tragedies are the stories that don't end in happily ever after; as we get older, especially, people become more drawn to tragedies. Why? Because life sucks and then you die, BUT at least you didn't marry your mom. The main point is that tragedies are relatable in the fact that our lives will always encounter some sort of problematic situation and you will never have a euphoric life, but it always you to feel somewhat better about your own life because it could  in fact be worse.

As David E Rivas explains it, after watching these tragedies, we get a feeling of catharsis-an emotional release- and watching them is said to help you project your own emotions, or lets you forget about your own problems for a little while, as you watch someone else have to handle theirs. As I have alluded to in the beginning, Oedipus's was a tragic character with no grand characteristic other than his social stature. This makes it m…